Tim Lincecum, 2 Cy Youngs and a ring. He has had a phenomenal career and durability was the only thing that supposedly was going to hold him back, He proved the critics wrong. Going forward I think that Tim will be slightly better than Josh. I like Tims arsenal of pitches better than Johnson and when he gets older it will be easier for him to reinvent himself as opposed to Johnson. Although I think Josh will be a great pitcher as well.