May 9, 2011 #61 Rice18 I'm emotionally vested in me. Joined Feb 15, 2010 Messages 7,142 Reaction score 473 King Felix Wright or Rodriguez
May 9, 2011 Thread starter #62 Phil The Thrill Well-Known Member Joined Aug 29, 2009 Messages 12,785 Reaction score 218 Wright. Lester or JJ
May 9, 2011 #63 RipCity32 King Of The East Hall of Fame Joined Jan 22, 2006 Messages 88,197 Reaction score 730 Lester. JV or CC
May 9, 2011 #64 Rice18 I'm emotionally vested in me. Joined Feb 15, 2010 Messages 7,142 Reaction score 473 CC (a tad homer) Cano or Pujols
May 9, 2011 #65 Y Yankees2772 RIP Derek Boogaard Hall of Fame Joined Oct 25, 2009 Messages 18,978 Reaction score 645 Pujols every day of the week. Troy Tulowitzki or Hanley Ramirez?
May 9, 2011 #66 RipCity32 King Of The East Hall of Fame Joined Jan 22, 2006 Messages 88,197 Reaction score 730 Tulo. Cabby or Tex.
May 9, 2011 #67 Y Yankees2772 RIP Derek Boogaard Hall of Fame Joined Oct 25, 2009 Messages 18,978 Reaction score 645 Cabrera Buster Posey or Carlos Santana?
May 9, 2011 #68 Rice18 I'm emotionally vested in me. Joined Feb 15, 2010 Messages 7,142 Reaction score 473 Right now I take Carlos JJ or Halladay
May 9, 2011 #69 Elite PND SZN Joined Feb 28, 2010 Messages 18,915 Reaction score 1,162 Doc for this season, JJ going forward. Prince or Howard?
May 9, 2011 #70 Mexi #2 SG of all time #13 Hall of Fame Joined Jul 6, 2006 Messages 59,823 Reaction score 582 Prince justin upton or jay bruce
May 9, 2011 #71 Rice18 I'm emotionally vested in me. Joined Feb 15, 2010 Messages 7,142 Reaction score 473 Chocolate pudding face Yankees starting pitchers or Red Sox starting pitchers
May 10, 2011 #72 cruzg24 It is what it is Joined May 18, 2008 Messages 21,184 Reaction score 209 Yankees starting pitching Mark Buerhle or Tim Hudson
May 10, 2011 #73 D dcpwner Well-Known Member Joined May 24, 2006 Messages 8,717 Reaction score 127 Hudson, only cuz i hat the White Sox lolol but really, Buerhle Alexei Ramirez or Starlin Castro
May 10, 2011 #74 Elite PND SZN Joined Feb 28, 2010 Messages 18,915 Reaction score 1,162 Starlin easy. Kid is a flat out stud. Gonna be a mainstay in the Cubs lineup for the next 15 years. Cano or Pedroia?
Starlin easy. Kid is a flat out stud. Gonna be a mainstay in the Cubs lineup for the next 15 years. Cano or Pedroia?
May 10, 2011 #75 cruzg24 It is what it is Joined May 18, 2008 Messages 21,184 Reaction score 209 Cano, but I love how Pedroia hustles. Carlos Lee or Adam Dunn
May 10, 2011 Thread starter #76 Phil The Thrill Well-Known Member Joined Aug 29, 2009 Messages 12,785 Reaction score 218 Lee. Doc or Santana?
May 10, 2011 #77 cruzg24 It is what it is Joined May 18, 2008 Messages 21,184 Reaction score 209 Doc. I love Santana but lets be real, Santana has been injured and hasnt had the chance to shine in the playoffs. Doc is a beast. Joakim Soria or Brian Wilson
Doc. I love Santana but lets be real, Santana has been injured and hasnt had the chance to shine in the playoffs. Doc is a beast. Joakim Soria or Brian Wilson
May 10, 2011 #78 The Guid The Guid abides Hall of Fame Joined Mar 31, 2006 Messages 24,895 Reaction score 214 THE BEARD, despite his recent struggles Jurrjens or Kershaw
May 10, 2011 #79 Y Yankees2772 RIP Derek Boogaard Hall of Fame Joined Oct 25, 2009 Messages 18,978 Reaction score 645 Kershaw for sure Tommy Hanson or Matt Cain?
May 10, 2011 #80 The Guid The Guid abides Hall of Fame Joined Mar 31, 2006 Messages 24,895 Reaction score 214 Gonna go with Cain Chipper Jones or Vladdy Guerrero