MLB Player Rankings 2017: #2 Catcher

[Phil The Thrill]

Vote away. Results below. 
 
http://www.sportsins...howtopic=107540

 

[PWNdroia]

Molina. May have been wrong to pick him as #1, but he's definitely up there.

 

[brett05]

Gotta be Contreras.  Folks are looking too much to the past and not current/future.

 

[brett05]

Second look, I'd be ok with Sanchez as #2.  It's like 2a and 2b with these guys.

 

[PWNdroia]

Gotta be Contreras.  Folks are looking too much to the past and not current/future.

Completely disagree with this consensus.  To me, the past means more than what a player is projected to do in the coming years.  That's why a lot of my picks have been different from others, because I depend on the past more.

 

[brett05]

Completely disagree with this consensus.  To me, the past means more than what a player is projected to do in the coming years.  That's why a lot of my picks have been different from others, because I depend on the past more.

Where re your votes for Babe Ruth?  Or Carlos Beltran?  The past can count, but you seem to be over emphasizing it.

 

[PWNdroia]

Where re your votes for Babe Ruth?  Or Carlos Beltran?  The past can count, but you seem to be over emphasizing it.

I probably am, but I more faith in what's done then what hasn't happened yet.

 

[brett05]

I probably am, but I more faith in what's done then what hasn't happened yet.

you have to be careful projecting too

 

[catman]

I'll go with Yadi at #3.

 

[PWNdroia]

The reason I pick Yadi is because he has a history of making teams better. He made the Cardinals great for several years and the Puerto Rico WBC team would have never gotten to the Finals without him. Aside from his stats, he's got the right demeanor and he makes every pitcher better.

 

[Phil The Thrill]

Contreras has this one