- Joined
- Jun 17, 2007
- Messages
- 127,713
- Reaction score
- 2,100
do these super bowl winners really wanna go to disney world?
My thoughts exactly.Who would ever not wanna go to disney world?
And that is why they are the only elite QBs, consistency.Im not gonna go rush and say "SO AND SO IS #5" because of one good year. Consistency is key, and outside of Brady, Peyton, Brees, and Rodgers, none of the other quarterbacks have proven to be all that consistent imo
Player A plays his home games in the windiest stadium, and largest market in the NFL. Player B just lobs the ball up to his 6'4+ receiving core in sunny, insignificant California for nine games per season.lol if Brady throws that ball to Welker a tiny bit lower, and Wes catches it, this conversation doesnt even occur.
Giants won the 1st Super Bowl because of their defense, 100%. Eli got MVP because no WR/TE/RB had a breakout game, and they cant give the award to an entire defensive line. It was Strahan, Osi, and Tuck in 2007 that got them the win. But you give the award to the QB most of the time; only exception is when a single non-QB has a great game.
Eli definitely played well in this Super Bowl, but they won because Tuck owned. He made Logan Mankins his bitch, and rushed Brady so much. JPP played great as well. But because not one person stood out so much, they had to give the MVP to Eli.
Like, if Jerod Mayo forced a fumble on that last Giants drive, and New England recovered and won, Brady gets MVP, not Mayo. Its a meaningless award, to be honest.
I think 95% of NFL fans can agree Brady, Rodgers, and Brees, in no order, are the Top 3.
Aside from Giants homers, Peyton is still the superior Manning, and is #4.
Eli v Roethlisberger v Stafford v Rivers. Eli and Stafford had great years this year, Roethlisberger was solid, Rivers threw many INTs
My #5 is Rivers. Compare the stats for Eli and Rivers for 2010+2011
Player A: 8,935 yards, 60 TDs, 41 INTs, 62.0% completion, 89.2 passer rating
Player B: 9,334 yards, 57 TDs, 33 INTs, 64.5% completion, 95.0 passer rating
Player A is Eli, Player 2 is Rivers. I dont know how anyone can take player A over player B, unless they want a worse QB. Remember, for as bad of a year Rivers had this year, Eli in 2010 was worse
Same hereI'll refer to Tom Brady as Tom Brady.
IDK bout everyone else.
O rly?Just wanted to add that the way to build a championship contender is through the draft:
2004 Philip Rivers North Carolina State Quarterback (Traded for Eli Manning)
2005 Corey Webster (#1 CB on the team) *2nd Round Pick
2006 Mathias Kiwanuka Boston College Defensive end (Starting LB'er on the team)
2007 Aaron Ross Texas Defensive back (#2 CB on the team)
2008 Kenny Phillips Miami (FL) Defensive back (Starting Safety on the team)
2009 Hakeem Nicks North Carolina Wide receiver (#1 WR on the team)
2010 Jason Pierre-Paul South Florida Defensive end (#1 DE on the team)
2011 Prince Amukamara Nebraska Defensive back (#3 CB on the team)