Matthew Stafford takes a shot at Cris Carter

[bosoxlover12]

The guy is probably the best wide receiver in the game right now

Welker is better right now, Calvin is #2

 

[The Young One]

Runs his routes well, fast, can outjump any CB by a couple feet, catches basically anything that comes his way.
I mean, what type of answer are you looking for here?
Watch some Lions games, see the catches he makes.

Not even trying to bait..but you do realize that answer can be said for Fitz/Andre too right?

 

[WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18]

Not even trying to bait..but you do realize that answer can be said for Fitz/Andre too right?

Who cares... Calvin Johnson is a stud, I don't care if he's considered #1, #2, #3, #4, #50, #60.. The guy is a beast and nobody would complain if he played for their respective team. You can't go wrong with any of the three - Calvin, Andre, Fitzgerald.

 

[Elite]

Who cares... Calvin Johnson is a stud, I don't care if he's considered #1, #2, #3, #4, #50, #60.. The guy is a beast and nobody would complain if he played for their respective team. You can't go wrong with any of the three - Calvin, Andre, Fitzgerald.

You say this every time someone argues about the top players at a certain position.

Nobody cares.

 

[RipCity32]

Not even trying to bait..but you do realize that answer can be said for Fitz/Andre too right?

Exactly, so why is he considered worst than the two.
To me, it's just opinionated who is #1. You can't go wrong with any 3..

 

[kam.]

Exactly, so why is he considered worst than the two.
To me, it's just opinionated who is #1. You can't go wrong with any 3..

Andre does it better than them all.

Fitz and Calvin is near the same, except Fitz is better at going up and getting the ball and getting seperation.

Therefore.

Andre > > Fitz > Calvin.

Its understood that Calvin is a Lion, and you have some favoritism there.. but there is a "wrong answer".. Its not like all 3 are the same players.

 

[RipCity32]

You are entitled to your own opinion.

 

[kam.]

You are entitled to your own opinion.

You still havent presented a reason why you believe hes better than the two.

You stated something that Andre and Fitz do better than Calvin.. then said hes in the same league.. Make up your mind.

 

[bosoxlover12]

Andre does it better than them all.

Fitz and Calvin is near the same, except Fitz is better at going up and getting the ball and getting seperation.

Therefore.

Andre > > Fitz > Calvin.

Its understood that Calvin is a Lion, and you have some favoritism there.. but there is a "wrong answer".. Its not like all 3 are the same players.

no, there isnt a wrong answer lol

if he was titans fan, and saying Britt is a top reciever, then yes thats wrong

But Calvin is just as good as the 2 ahead of him


But using your logic, i can say

Peterson>> Cj28>MJD

but you would argue that, as "Jones-Drew is an equal or better RB than those 2". How is that different than Rip and inf saying Calvin is equal to Andre/Fitz?

 

[JoshHoward5]

When I first saw this thread on the forum tho.. I thought it said "Matthew Stafford Takes A Shit"

This sounds like a much better thread.

 

[RipCity32]

Like what fucking fact are you basing your ideas off of?
You said Andre does it better? Is there some statistical fact or algorithm that claims that, or is that just kam's "I know everything so it's true" stat?
Cause you can say Andre is better at everything all you want, but at the end of the day that is your own damn opinion.

 

[kam.]

no, there isnt a wrong answer lol

if he was titans fan, and saying Britt is a top reciever, then yes thats wrong

But Calvin is just as good as the 2 ahead of him


But using your logic, i can say

Peterson>> Cj28>MJD

but you would argue that, as "Jones-Drew is an equal or better RB than those 2". How is that different than Rip and inf saying Calvin is equal to Andre/Fitz?

But MJD is better though.. Hes the better all around player. Catches, Runs, Fast, Block, ETC.

Like what fucking fact are you basing your ideas off of?
You said Andre does it better? Is there some statistical fact or algorithm that claims that, or is that just kam's "I know everything so it's true" stat?
Cause you can say Andre is better at everything all you want, but at the end of the day that is your own damn opinion.

Because by fucking watching them, you can just fucking tell whos better.

If you wanna bring stats into this, we can do that too.

 

[RipCity32]

It's clear you don't watch the Lions.

 

[kam.]

It's clear you don't watch the Lions.

But I do?

Nice to know you're like.. Tapping my TV or wtfe.

 

[RipCity32]

If you watched the Lions it would be just as clear to you that he is just as good.
I don't know what Lions you are watching. Nittany Lions or something?

 

[kam.]

If you watched the Lions it would be just as clear to you that he is just as good.
I don't know what Lions you are watching. Nittany Lions or something?

I've watched the Lions.. Im not saying Calvin isn't good.. hes top 3.. but hes just not better than Andre nor Fitz.

 

[RipCity32]

Once again, your opinion. Moving on.

 

[kam.]

Well whats the point in pulling stats out if your just going to be like "Calvin didn't have a QB" .. blah blah blah.

 

[bosoxlover12]

But MJD is better though.. Hes the better all around player. Catches, Runs, Fast, Block, ETC.

You telling me MJD is faster than Johnson? lmao.

All three are fairly equal recievers

Gimme actual EVIDENCE that Jones Drew is better

 

[Elite]

But MJD is better though.. Hes the better all around player. Catches, Runs, Fast, Block, ETC.

AP > MJD.

Not close.