Is Carson Palmer a Future HOFer?

[Sportacular]

Personally, I don't see him as a future HOF'er. I think if he has a few more excellent years, then he could have a shot. Winning a super bowl would greatly increase his chances though. I love the guy, as a cardinals fan, but I don't see it as of right now.

 

[Mentch]

No, sorry but even a title wouldnt make him a HOF'er. I would put Tony Romo in the HOF far before I put Carson Palmer in if they were to both retire at this moment, and Romo is clearly not a HOF'er at this moment. There is no case to be made for putting Carson Palmer in the HOF. If we're going to induct him, we need to also induct Kenny Anderson, Boomer Esiason, Phil Simms, Randall Cunningham, and most importantly, Ken Stabler

 

[Baller]

He is not a future HOF'er. He had a few good seasons, but besides that he hasn't been very effective.

 

[Cloud 9]

At this point, no way