Hall of Fame Inductees

[brett05]

 
I was going off of guys who were RP their entire careers...so i was not way off. Hoffman is #2 and Mo will be #3. 
 
 
looking back, I thought that Rollie spent more time as a SP....he was a RP for 90% of his innings. So i guess I could include him in he list as well

Goose, Rollie, Sutter, Wilhelm
Eckersley is in the Hall for everything as a reliever and so much more so to hide his awful first go as a starter.
 
Sory, you're stuff is fantastic, but this take is dead wrong.

 

[brett05]

Guerrero going in as an angel makes me upset

We agree, it should be as an Expo. 

 

[bosoxlover12]

We agree, it should be as an Oriole. 

FTFY

 

[brett05]

FTFY

LOL...troll away my friend

 

[CameronCrazy06]

Never made the argument for #1.  Way to strawman.  I said he's among the alltime greats at the position.  And hey look, top 10 would be among the all time greats.

I am for Rolen too.  You look at his numbers and he's right there in the discussion of the best 3b of all time

Right up there with the all time greats is not this.

 

[PWNdroia]

Schilling and Wagner are getting fucked on this and its for no other reason than terrible relationships with the very writers who hold the ballots. I mean, Schilling has 11 wins and a sub 2.3 ERA in the postseason.

And I think Vlad is going in as an Angel because hes going to be their first. Its also where he won a ring and became recognized as a superstar.

Don't forget Schilling is also in the top 20 for the most strikeouts... way better than Glavine statistically.

 

[brett05]

Right up there with the all time greats is not this.

I can see what you are saying.  You read that as third baseman and I meant it as third basemen.

 

[CameronCrazy06]

I can see what you are saying.  You read that as third baseman and I meant it as third basemen.