Can Tim Lincecum win his third straight Cy Young award?

[elcheato]

He shouldn't have won it, the only person deserving was Chris Carpenter in my mind.. That is what I am saying, not hard to comprehend.

 

[playmaker7]

He shouldn't have won it, the only person deserving was Chris Carpenter in my mind.. That is what I am saying, not hard to comprehend.

Its hard to comprehend when you're saying its given to one player who deserves it, but you think a player who didn't win it deserved it...

Thats contradictory

Lincecum was a deserving winner man. He's arguably the best pitcher in the league now and had a great season...

 

[elcheato]

Its hard to comprehend when you're saying its given to one player who deserves it, but you think a player who didn't win it deserved it...

Thats contradictory

Lincecum was a deserving winner man. He's arguably the best pitcher in the league now and had a great season...

I said, only 1 person deserves the award every year because it is only given to 1 person.. Don't understand why it would be deserving to 3 guys? Linceum was not the best pitcher in the NL last year.

And how is it contradictory LOL, I am saying Carpenter is the one who deserved the award and who should have won it. Not my fault the voters like the younger, more recognizable name.

 

[playmaker7]

I said, only 1 person deserves the award every year because it is only given to 1 person.. Don't understand why it would be deserving to 3 guys? Linceum was not the best pitcher in the NL last year.

And how is it contradictory LOL, I am saying Carpenter is the one who deserved the award and who should have won it. Not my fault the voters like the younger, more recognizable name.

Lincecum had a Cy Young worthy season...and he did it on a non-playoff team. He won the award at the conclusion of his great season...whats so hard to understand?

Carpenter was great, I'll even say I had him winning the Cy Young, but Lincecum no doubt in my mind was a deserving winner.

When I say "he deserved it", I mean that he had the kind of season where him winning it doesn't surprise me

 

[TuckerIntensity]

He definitely could. Will be interesting to see him, Halladay, and a healthy Santana this year. It could be one dominant year for the top pitchers in the NL.

 

[FutureTwin]

no he won't, Roy Halladay all the way