Better QB: Ben or Flacco?

[East]

Who would you take and why?

 

[RipCity32]

Big Ben easily. His two Super Bowl rings are enough to pick him for me.

 

[Stro]

I'd take Big Ben 10 times out of 10.

He makes plays - important plays when it matters, his escapability and mobility is of course key to his success. Throw in 2 SuperBowl rings, his career completion %, wins & playoff performances and you have your winner

Flacco has a mean(er) running game and mean(er) defense. Pittsburgh relies more on Roethlisberger for their wins.

I don't even think this is close:

Big Ben is top 6 QB.
I don't think Flacco is Top 10, he is in the lower echelons of the Top Half of league QBs.

 

[jonathanlambert33]

Ben, very easily.

 

[Elite]

This is comparing fast food to a steak dinner...

Big Ben easy

 

[WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18]

I'd take Big Ben 10 times out of 10.

He makes plays - important plays when it matters, his escapability and mobility is of course key to his success. Throw in 2 SuperBowl rings, his career completion %, wins & playoff performances and you have your winner

Flacco has a mean(er) running game and mean(er) defense. Pittsburgh relies more on Roethlisberger for their wins.

I don't even think this is close:

Big Ben is top 6 QB.
I don't think Flacco is Top 10, he is in the lower echelons of the Top Half of league QBs.

Well, I wouldn't say the Ravens defense is better or meaner than the Steelers, they are pretty equal in that regard. But yeah, I would agree with Ben > Joe. I look at Flacco as a top 15 QB and Ben is close to top 5. Joe Flacco also has a better offensive line and running back. Ben is always running for his life, but finds a way to make plays and has proven he can win the big games.

 

[.infamous]

Yea Big Ben for sure.

 

[elcheato]

This is comparing fast food to a steak dinner...

Big Ben easy

Well if you're getting the steak dinner from non steak joints, then its no good.

Ben Roethlisberger is an applebees steak.

 

[Elite]

He's a steak dinner in terms of this comparison, he's the fast food when you compare him to Brady etc...

 

[jonathanlambert33]

Who is the guy that loves Flacco? Yanks?

 

[Mooche]

Who is the guy that loves Flacco? Yanks?

That would be correct.

This is Ben Roethlisberger and it isn't even close.

 

[WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18]

Who is the guy that loves Flacco? Yanks?

Well Yanks is definitely the guy that likes Flacco, but he likes Tebow even more..

 

[kam.]

What kinda question is this? Whats next? Whos better.. Henne vs Brady?