All Encompassing Trade Rumours Thread

[brett05]

Told you so

 

[bosoxlover12]

told us what? that package is nowhere close to moncada + devers SMH

 

[brett05]

Told you that the'd get two great people in.   I never said Q would get Yoan.  The team got better than Devers in Eloy.  But you Redsox fans are blind.

 

[Giantmetfan07]

You said two top 50, two 75-125. They didn't get that 2nd part. Those two guys weren't even in their Top 30 prospects according to MLB.

 

[Mexi]

They traded eloy yay

 

[Phil The Thrill]

You legit said Quintana would bring in a Sale haul. Which didn't happen.
 
And Jimenez is a very comparable prospect to Devers. Baseball America has them at 5 and 6 respectively. 

 

[Mexi]

https://twitter.com/JonHeyman/status/885540163832741888

Ill give them stripling or brock stewart
Young controllable good starters

 

[catman]

Quintana brought back #8, #63 and a couple of AAA roster fillers.  Not a huge haul.
MLB.com rankings.  #'s 5 & 83 according to Baseball America.

 

[brett05]

You said two top 50, two 75-125. They didn't get that 2nd part. Those two guys weren't even in their Top 30 prospects according to MLB.

Absolutely true.

 

[catman]

In what world is #5 or 8 and #63 or 83 plus 2 AAA roster fillers the haul you said Quintana would bring back?  I don't even want to visit there.
Yes he brought the Sox a bit of talent to continue their rebuild of the farm system, but it is not the huge haul you predicted.

 

[brett05]

You legit said Quintana would bring in a Sale haul. Which didn't happen.
 
And Jimenez is a very comparable prospect to Devers. Baseball America has them at 5 and 6 respectively. 

I never said that they would.  You are wrong. 
 
and MLB has him at what 12 so it's not the same.

 

[brett05]

time to call up the Nationals and inquire about Robles.  Do Robertson and Kahnle with a minor league arm like maybe Carson Fulmer and get it done Hahn.

 

[catman]

I don't see the Nationals trading for Robertson.  Kinzler, maybe.

 

[Phil The Thrill]

Rumors are Quintana is traded before the season starts again.  This could be quite a haul for the Whitesox.  Possibly on the same level as the Red Sox deal with Sale.

 

[catman]

Mad Dog just said that the Sox should have held out for Ian Happ.  He's far better than Jimenez.  They might not have gotten the pitching prospect, but they would have improved their outfield defense immediately.  I concur.

 

[brett05]

 

Rumors are Quintana is traded before the season starts again.  This could be quite a haul for the Whitesox.  Possibly on the same level as the Red Sox deal with Sale.

 

Thanks.  You've show where I reported him traded and that he could get as high as Sale.  Nothing about would bring in.  So I guess you quoting is your way of saying you are wrong.  I agree, you are.  You are forgiven.

 

[brett05]

Mad Dog just said that the Sox should have held out for Ian Happ.  He's far better than Jimenez.  They might not have gotten the pitching prospect, but they would have improved their outfield defense immediately.  I concur.

Happ in the OF is not something anyone wants.  Granted Jimenez is an adventure himself, but he has a superior ceiling than Happ.  Happ is a MI guy and not something the WhiteSox need.

 

[CameronCrazy06]

https://twitter.com/JonHeyman/status/885540163832741888

Ill give them stripling or brock stewart
Young controllable good starters

I had a vision of this the other day. I'd miss Britton so much, but I think he'll be going. Would love to see him go there.

 

[catman]

If Britton is healthy, that would give the Dodgers a very short game.  Britton in the 8th and then Jansen in the 9th?  7 inning games are always nice.

 

[catman]

Happ in the OF is not something anyone wants.  Granted Jimenez is an adventure himself, but he has a superior ceiling than Happ.  Happ is a MI guy and not something the WhiteSox need.
 

Happ would be a whole lot better than Garcia in the outfield.  Garcia is a horrible fielder.