ADFS Greatest NFL QB of All Time Top 10 (#2 Voting)!

[RunSoHard]

Who is the Greatest NFL Quarterback to ever play the game? Place your vote and tell us who you voted for and why. There will be a list of players who aren't on the current top ten voting but will move up to replace the player voted in to each number slot. Tell us who should be on the list next and who should be added to the list if they are not on there already

Top 10
1. Joe Montana (San Francisco 49ers)

Nominees
Tom Brady (New England Patriots)
Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts)
Brett Favre (Green Bay Packers)
John Elway (Denver Broncos)
Johnny Unitas (Baltimore Colts)
Dan Marino (Miami Dolphins)
Steve Young (San Francisco 49ers)
Roger Staubach (Dallas Cowboys)
Otto Graham (Cleveland Browns)
Terry Bradshaw (Pittsburgh Steelers)

Honorable Mentions
Fran Tarkenton (Minnesota Vikings)
Drew Brees (New Orleans Saints)
Bart Starr (Green Bay Packers)
Aaron Rodgers (Green Bay Packers)
Kurt Warner (St. Louis Rams)
Troy Aikman (Dallas Cowboys)

 

[RunSoHard]

Tom Brady for sure.

 

[Howard4mvp12]

as much as i hate the guy, tom brady is the perfect pick for #2

 

[Lynch Mob]

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Montana

 

[Howard4mvp12]

4-0>>>>4-2

 

[BNC]

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Montana

Are the SB's the reason for Brady>Manning?

 

[Lynch Mob]

Are the SB's the reason for Brady>Manning?

We got into it during the #1 voting. I look at stats, rings, supporting cast, and impact on players around him.

 

[Howard4mvp12]

Are the SB's the reason for Brady>Manning?

i wouldnt rank montana behind manning what so ever, very BOLD statement

 

[Lynch Mob]

4-0>>>>4-2

Throwing to Jerry Rice vs. Throwing to Deion Branch

 

[Howard4mvp12]

We got into it during the #1 voting. I look at stats, rings, supporting cast, and impact on players around him.

if you base it on all that, why rank joe at 3 and manning at 2 ? lol

 

[Howard4mvp12]

Throwing to Jerry Rice vs. Throwing to Deion Branch

forgetting troy brown ? lol

 

[Howard4mvp12]

Throwing to Jerry Rice vs. Throwing to Deion Branch

2 out of the 4 superbowl, branch participated

 

[Lynch Mob]

if you base it on all that, why rank joe at 3 and manning at 2 ? lol

Manning had better receivers. Give Brady 12 years of Marvin Harrison and 13 of Reggie Wayne.

 

[Lynch Mob]

2 out of the 4 superbowl, branch participated

So you're comparing Deion Branch and Troy Brown to Jerry Rice?

 

[Howard4mvp12]

Manning had better receivers. Give Brady 12 years of Marvin Harrison and 13 of Reggie Wayne.

we talking about manning and montana, yeah give brady randy moss and he breaks recordsssssss , something manning never did with both harrison and wayne

 

[Howard4mvp12]

So you're comparing Deion Branch and Troy Brown to Jerry Rice?

you're the one comparing them

 

[Lynch Mob]

we talking about manning and montana, yeah give brady randy moss and he breaks recordsssssss , something manning never did with both harrison and wayne

Brady had Randy Moss for 3 1/2 seasons

you're the one comparing them

They don't compare and that's my point.

 

[BNC]

We got into it during the #1 voting. I look at stats, rings, supporting cast, and impact on players around him.

Fair enough, can't really go wrong with either IMO

 

[Lynch Mob]

Fair enough, can't really go wrong with either IMO

Up until last season, I had always put Manning over Brady.

 

[BNC]

Up until last season, I had always put Manning over Brady.

So if they hand it off the Lynch and Seattle scores does your opinion change? I still have Manning higher, can't really say he's more accomplished though