How about we rename this thread to current players who if they retired today, would be in the hall of fame. Seems like only Ortiz has a shot here since it doesn't appear people are on the A-rod hype train.
Results here
http://www.sportsinsomnia.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=98744
Also, discuss here, but when we do relievers, do you guys want a top 5 for relievers and a top 5 for closers, combine them for a top 5, or combine them for a top 10?