Search results

I think it would be great for Judge to have a better Sophomore year, history speaks hard against that.  I'd love for Altuve to be MVP again, I don't think he'll ever be a team MVP again let alone a league one (speaks to how good the Astros are).  The MVP barring injury or a complete rebuild is...

People do because on this board most people were not born.   For those of us that lived it, there were no outstanding candidates from playoff type teams. 

Way to not focus on 2017.  You are new to baseball.  Welcome, the sport needs more fans.

Good luck showing that one

Again, his value to the Dodgers is so much greater than Votto to the Reds.

They made the playoffs with Paul

I agree with those first two quotes, the last is dumb.  No one remembers Votto.  No one watched the Reds.    Discounting how a team performs is dumb unless there are no clear performers for guys that helped a team.   Sorry, you folks picking best player for the award is wrong.  As it is for he...

There's no showing you the logic.  Oh well.

Clearly you are someone who thinks that MVP is best overall hitter.  That's not what the MVP is.

Votto in the lineup and out of the lineup is still dead last for the Reds.  His value was no where near the MOST

so you have no clue what the Dodgers did with CB in the lineup vs out of the lineup?

They did matter.  Management bailed as you stated and the players left under Molitor played their hearts out and got into the playoffs.  That fits the definition of a manager of the year perfectly.

New to baseball are ya?  Sorry, I take that back.   No one dismisses Player in these awards, but to not understand what valuable means and most valuable is just not getting it.   I looked a bit deeper and Stanton fell off in Sept/Oct and had three months of sub 900 ops.  Goldy one, but man was...

Lions Ravens Jaguars Texans Buccaneers Rams Saints Chiefs   Chargers Broncos Patriots   Eagles   Seahawks

Poor, sad, embarrassment, lazy, illogical, etc, etc,etc

Yes complain about the playoffs.  Why is admitting being wrong so hard?  Anyone?

I just want to know how Goldy doesn't win this with the two Rockies 2nd and 3rd.  The NL voting was POOR!

Girardi didn't build anything.  He's not the GM

QFT

That's not how Manager of the YEAR works