Best Division Of QBs?

[Rice18]

Yeah, NFC South really shouldn't be mentioned.
Way I see it though...

Rodgers = Brees
Stafford > Ryan
Cutler > Newton
Ponder < Freeman

Rodgers > Manning
Stafford > Romo
Cutler = Vick
Ponder < Griffin

Cutler is better then Stafford.

It is close, but I give the edge to Cutler.

Also lulz at Stafford and Cutler not being top 10. I am scared to watch Cutler actually having some WR's.

 

[.infamous]

After further review, I'll take the NFC North lol. Stafford. Rodgers. Cutler. Ponder. Ponder is the one that holds it down a little bit but he'll be alright and those other three are really good.

Threw out the challenge flag right?

 

[Teagz]

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Eli
Big Ben
Rivers
Stafford
Cutler
Schaub
Ryan
Vick
Romo

You guys are sleeping on Matt Schaub.

 

[bosoxlover12]

Schaub will never put up Top 10 numbers because of how good Arian Foster will be

 

[Teagz]

He can still put up the same numbers as the others in the debate for the No.10 spot. He threw for 4,000 yards in his past two full seasons and most likely would have last year had he not been injured.

 

[Hurricane Season]

And I think Foster's receiving ability would HELP Schaub put up top 10 numbers.

 

[jonathanlambert33]

The NFCN having Ponder as a starter is what pushes the NFCS in front for me.

 

[BwareDWare94]

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Eli
Big Ben
Rivers
Stafford
Cutler
Schaub
Ryan
Vick
Romo

You guys are sleeping on Matt Schaub.

Gotta move Romo ahead of all of them for that list to be legit.

 

[TTN2810]

Seriously dude, at this point I have to think you are just trolling us...
I've never ever seen anyone so obsessed with a sports player.

 

[Falcons11497]

Seriously dude, at this point I have to think you are just trolling us...
I've never ever seen anyone so obsessed with a sports player.

I know right
dude is ridiculous

 

[Rice18]

The NFCN having Ponder as a starter is what pushes the NFCS in front for me.

Comparing Aikman and Ponder during their rookie years

GP - 11 each
Completions - Ponder had 3 more
Attempts - Ponder had 2 Less
Completion % - Ponder has 1.4% better
Yards - Ponder has about 100 more
Average Yards - Ponder has .4 ypc more
TD - Ponder has 4 more TDs
Int - Ponder has 5 less INT
Rating - Ponder is about 15 more

Now the only stat worse - 5 Fumbles compared to 0

My whole point is that you can NOT just go off the rookie year of a player.

 

[Hurricane Season]

You also can't really compare QB statistics pre and post Ty Law rule.

 

[bosoxlover12]

Christian Ponder had more TD passes as a rookie than Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers had combined


Means nothing

 

[jonathanlambert33]

Comparing Aikman and Ponder during their rookie years

GP - 11 each
Completions - Ponder had 3 more
Attempts - Ponder had 2 Less
Completion % - Ponder has 1.4% better
Yards - Ponder has about 100 more
Average Yards - Ponder has .4 ypc more
TD - Ponder has 4 more TDs
Int - Ponder has 5 less INT
Rating - Ponder is about 15 more

Now the only stat worse - 5 Fumbles compared to 0

My whole point is that you can NOT just go off the rookie year of a player.

You can when the question doesn't ask you to take into account five years from now.

 

[BwareDWare94]

I'm not "obsessed." I'm just sick of people underrating Romo when he's one of the best QBs in the NFL. Fucking sick of it.

 

[NCSportsfan21]

If you’re taking Cutler by his career, he wins over Cam. If were basing this off last years performances, Killa Cam rapes Pussy Jay. And if it’s by careers well then Ryan wins over Stafford’s single good year.

Brees=Rodgers
Stafford>Ryan
Newton>Cutler
Freeman>Ponder

Brees=Rodgers
Ryan>Stafford
Cutler>Newton
Freeman>Ponder

Either way NFC South wins.

RG3 has done nothing in the NFL and by default looses except to another rookie or Curtis Painter, imo.

 

[RipCity32]

Cutler is better then Stafford.

It is close, but I give the edge to Cutler.

Also lulz at Stafford and Cutler not being top 10. I am scared to watch Cutler actually having some WR's.

Cutler is not better than Stafford.

If you’re taking Cutler by his career, he wins over Cam. If were basing this off last years performances, Killa Cam rapes Pussy Jay. And if it’s by careers well then Ryan wins over Stafford’s single good year.

Brees=Rodgers
Stafford>Ryan
Newton>Cutler
Freeman>Ponder

Brees=Rodgers
Ryan>Stafford
Cutler>Newton
Freeman>Ponder

Either way NFC South wins.

RG3 has done nothing in the NFL and by default looses except to another rookie or Curtis Painter, imo.

Matt Ryan is not better than Matt Stafford.

 

[Rice18]

Christian Ponder had more TD passes as a rookie than Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers had combined


Means nothing

Did they start and have the same amount of games played?

What you stated, means nothing.

 

[Rice18]

You can when the question doesn't ask you to take into account five years from now.

Yeah, but you are still dogging him. You can't judge him by 1 year.

This year he has more then just Percy, and I think Ponder will either improve drastically or show that he wasn't worth such an early pick.

 

[bosoxlover12]

GUYS, NOBODY IS BETTER THAN MATT STAFFORD


/rip