Who are you top 5 goalies today ?

[LeafsFan4Life]

1-Carey Price
2-Marc Andre Fleury
3-Ryan Miller
4-Henrik Lundqvist
5-Martin Brodeur

Carey Price isn't the best goalie in the NHL...

And how do you not have Thomas in your top 5?..

 

[NV]

1-Carey Price
2-Marc Andre Fleury
3-Ryan Miller
4-Henrik Lundqvist
5-Martin Brodeur

No way Price is the best goalie. Wouldn't put Brodeur in there either since this is current goalies today. And no Luongo?

 

[germany00]

1-Carey Price
2-Marc Andre Fleury
3-Ryan Miller
4-Henrik Lundqvist
5-Martin Brodeur

Where are the 3 vezina finalists?!?! lol

 

[Mr.Baller]

I actually forgot Lulu .. I knew I was forgot someone that's why decided to put Brodeur .. my bad guys !

This is my real top 5 ;

1-Carey Price
2-Roberto Luango
3-Ryan Miller
4-Henrik Lundqvist
5-Marc Andre Fleury

And I don't like Thomas even tho he had a great season ! but he should be at #5 I know ....

 

[germany00]

I actually forgot Lulu .. I knew I was forgot someone that's why decided to put Brodeur .. my bad guys !

This is my real top 5 ;

1-Carey Price
2-Roberto Luango
3-Ryan Miller
4-Henrik Lundqvist
5-Marc Andre Fleury

And I don't like Thomas even tho he had a great season ! but he should be at #5 I know ....

Why not Rinne?

 

[NV]

I actually forgot Lulu .. I knew I was forgot someone that's why decided to put Brodeur .. my bad guys !

This is my real top 5 ;

1-Carey Price
2-Roberto Luango
3-Ryan Miller
4-Henrik Lundqvist
5-Marc Andre Fleury

And I don't like Thomas even tho he had a great season ! but he should be at #5 I know ....

I'll actually agree with this list, not necessarily the order but the 5 goalies yes.

I know Thomas had an unreal season but I don't think he'll follow it up this season personally.

 

[Mr.Baller]

Why not Rinne?

I believe him and Thomas both had great seasons last year but not sure if they could repeat the success that's the main reason why they aren't on my top ! I could be making a mistake with Fleury but the guy as proved more then Rinne until now ....

 

[The Guid]

I'll actually agree with this list, not necessarily the order but the 5 goalies yes.

I know Thomas had an unreal season but I don't think he'll follow it up this season personally.

It doesn't matter what you think he'll do next season though, it's top 5 "today". Thomas not on anyone's list right now is just wrong.

 

[germany00]

I believe him and Thomas both had great seasons last year but not sure if they could repeat the success that's the main reason why they aren't on my top ! I could be making a mistake with Fleury but the guy as proved more then Rinne until now ....

But Rinne had an amazing year for his first year starting

 

[NV]

It doesn't matter what you think he'll do next season though, it's top 5 "today". Thomas not on anyone's list right now is just wrong.

Yeah, I don't think he's a top 5 goalie anymore now that the season is over and done with.

If this was a list of top 5 goalies from last season then yeah he makes the list obviously.

 

[Mr.Baller]

It doesn't matter what you think he'll do next season though, it's top 5 "today". Thomas not on anyone's list right now is just wrong.

I didn't see the top 5 today -_-' ... In that case yes Thomas sould be in my top 5 instead of Fleury .

 

[dh1333]

Thomas is one of GOATS so he is in my top 20

 

[The Guid]

Yeah, I don't think he's a top 5 goalie anymore now that the season is over and done with.

If this was a list of top 5 goalies from last season then yeah he makes the list obviously.

The season is over and done with but you'd rather base your top 5 current goalies on your own predictions for next season rather than what they've actually done over the last year?

 

[germany00]

I didn't see the top 5 today -_-' ... In that case yes Thomas sould be in my top 5 instead of Fleury .

.... And Rinne? :huh2:

 

[Mr.Baller]

Price,Lundqvist,Lulu and Miller are all better then Rinne bro

 

[NV]

The season is over and done with but you'd rather base your top 5 current goalies on your own predictions for next season rather than what they've actually done over the last year?

Basically lol. I don't think Thomas is going to be a top 5 goalie anymore. Then again he was also not even considered the starter at the beginning of the season so I could just as well be completely wrong.

 

[The Guid]

S'cool, I was just trying to understand your reasoning even though I disagree completely lol

 

[germany00]

MY list as of the end of last season (no predictions)

1-Thomas
2-Rinne
3-Luongo
4-Price
5-Lundqvist


BOOM

 

[NV]

S'cool, I was just trying to understand your reasoning even though I disagree completely lol

Haha fair enough, guess we'll just have to wait and see

 

[The Guid]

Personally, I'd go Lundqvist ahead of Price. Price and Miller are tied for 5, for me, but that's a list I can't argue