QB rankings.

[kam.]

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Brees
4. Manning
5. Roethlisberger
6. Rivers.
7. Vick
8. Freeman
9. Flacco
10. Ryan
11. E. Manning
12. Romo
13. Cassel
14. Schaub
15. Bradford
16. Sanchez
17. Garrard
18. Orton
19. Cutler
20. Fitzpatrick
21. Stafford
22. Hasselbeck
23. McNabb
24. Palmer
25. McCoy
26. Young
27. Campbell
28. Alex Smith
29. Henne
30. Bulger

http://twitter.com/#!/RossTuckerNFL

Did them this morning.. How ya feel?

I know DWill isn't going to like Freeman and Ryan ahead of Eli (Which is what I called).

I know Colt fans won't like Manning #4.

I know Lion fans Don't like Stafford that far down either..

Seems about right to me however.

 

[VC15]

I'm fine with Eli at 11 (anywhere between 8-12), but I'd like to see Ryan and Freeman sustain that success before putting them in the top 10.

 

[kam.]

I'm fine with Eli at 11 (anywhere between 8-12), but I'd like to see Ryan and Freeman sustain that success before putting them in the top 10.

Theres still some QBs I'd rather have after 11 than Eli.

Freeman and Ryan are both better than Eli.

 

[Yankees2772]

Flacco > Freeman for sure man...

 

[jonathanlambert33]

I think Rodgers is too high, flip he and Peyton and the top 5 is good. Give Rodgers one more season before you put him in with guys like Brady, Manning, and Brees.

Next thing is Matt Ryan at 10, I don't know where he should be on this list, but I'd take Romo and Schaub over Ryan.

Orton < Cutler

 

[kam.]

I think Rodgers is too high, flip he and Peyton and the top 5 is good. Give Rodgers one more season before you put him in with guys like Brady, Manning, and Brees.

Next thing is Matt Ryan at 10, I don't know where he should be on this list, but I'd take Romo and Schaub over Ryan.

Orton < Cutler

Rodgers is better than Manning RIGHT NOW IMO.

Rodgers has been putting up good seasons ever since he was given the starting Job in 2008.


Cutler is an INT King. I'd rate Orton just above him.

I'd also take Ryan above Schaub and Romo.

Ryan just has something that screams "Franchise QB". Hes younger than both Romo and Schaub and better.

 

[jonathanlambert33]

He's not better than Romo or Schaub, he may be in the near future, but he isn't now.

I've even heard some Falcon fans admit to Schaub being better than Ryan.

 

[kam.]

He's not better than Romo or Schaub, he may be in the near future, but he isn't now.

I've even heard some Falcon fans admit to Schaub being better than Ryan.

This is coming from somebody who loves Schaub (Even though hes a AFC South QB)

Matt Ryan is better than Matt Schaub.

Schaub is a good QB, don't get me wrong. Matt Ryan has atleast lead his team to the playoffs twice in his short Career.

Schaub has been a Texan since like 2007 with Andre, Owen Daniels, RBs, Etc.. still no playoffs.

I don't want to hear the "Well his defense is horrible" excuse. The Colts defense has always been horrible. Good QBs carry their team.

 

[VC15]

Schaub is a good QB, don't get me wrong. Matt Ryan has atleast lead his team to the playoffs twice in his short
Career.

How many postseason wins does he have?

 

[kam.]

How many postseason wins does he have?

How many does Schaub have?

 

[Yankees2772]

How many postseason wins does he have?

The same amount that Eli has without Plaxico.

 

[VC15]

How many does Schaub have?

I'm not even saying that Schaub is better than Ryan. However, it's hard to ignore the fact that Ryan has failed miserably in his two trips to the postseason.

 

[kam.]

I'm not even saying that Schaub is better than Ryan. However, it's hard to ignore the fact that Ryan has failed miserably in his two trips to the postseason.

Id rather have a QB who makes it to the Playoffs and gives his team a chance to compete than to be Playoff Favorites early September and to fall to 5-10 at the end of the year. Like Schaub always does.

 

[jonathanlambert33]

This is coming from somebody who loves Schaub (Even though hes a AFC South QB)

Matt Ryan is better than Matt Schaub.

Schaub is a good QB, don't get me wrong. Matt Ryan has atleast lead his team to the playoffs twice in his short Career.

Schaub has been a Texan since like 2007 with Andre, Owen Daniels, RBs, Etc.. still no playoffs.

I don't want to hear the "Well his defense is horrible" excuse. The Colts defense has always been horrible. Good QBs carry their team.

You can also argue that Turner is carrying the Falcons, not Matt Ryan. The Falcons are, a run first team of course.

I know that Schaub is 761-1157, 65.7%, 9,140 yards, 53 td's, 27 int's, 95.4 QB rating. While Matt Ryan is 620-1022, 60.6%, 6,621 yards, 40 td's, 23 int's, 83.3 QB rating over the last two seasons. That's a huge difference. Schaub throws nearly a yard and a half more per attempt, has a higher td percentage, and has basically the same int percentage.

 

[kam.]

You can also argue that Turner is carrying the Falcons, not Matt Ryan. The Falcons are, a run first team of course.

I know that Schaub is 761-1157, 65.7%, 9,140 yards, 53 td's, 27 int's, 95.4 QB rating. While Matt Ryan is 620-1022, 60.6%, 6,621 yards, 40 td's, 23 int's, 83.3 QB rating over the last two seasons. That's a huge difference. Schaub throws nearly a yard and a half more per attempt, has a higher td percentage, and has basically the same int percentage.

Michael Turner only had like 7 more carries than Arian Foster... I forgot.. its Michael Turner that won them games.

 

[jonathanlambert33]

Michael Turner only had like 7 more carries than Arian Foster... I forgot.. its Michael Turner that won them games.

Point being, you can't compare the Texans and Falcons. Two completely different styles, on both sides of the ball.

BTW, the Falcons ran the ball 74 more times last season than the Texans. Like I said, Michael Turner (well I guess the ground game) carries the Falcons, not Matt Ryan.

 

[kam.]

Point being, you can't compare the Texans and Falcons. Two completely different styles, on both sides of the ball.

BTW, the Falcons ran the ball 74 more times last season than the Texans. Like I said, Michael Turner (well I guess the ground game) carries the Falcons, not Matt Ryan.

If you seriously think the Falcons would be Just as good without Matt Ryan, you're on crack. Michael Turner doesn't carry them.

 

[WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18]

If Palmer is that bad, thank god he's retiring.

 

[kam.]

If Palmer is that bad, thank god he's retiring.

Palmer is.

We tried telling you.

You was blind to it earlier in the year.

"its all BOBS FAULT, Carson is a top 10 and use to be top 3 QB dammit"

 

[WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18]

Palmer is.

We tried telling you.

You was blind to it earlier in the year.

"its all BOBS FAULT, Carson is a top 10 and use to be top 3 QB dammit"

He was for one year and then he got injured in the playoff game against the Steelers in '05 and hasn't been the same since. I probably don't want to believe it more than anything. I've always been a big Palmer fan since his days at USC and I hate it has come to this. I just wonder if he's really that bad, or is it just the Bengals (losing) has gotten to his head. At times this year I seen a Palmer that was really bad and then at times I seen a Palmer that was pretty good, especially the Chargers game. A change of scenery might do him good.