Who are you top 5 goalies today ?

[Rice18]

1. Ryan Miller
2. Thomas Vokun
3. Martin Broduer
4. Niklas Bäckström
5. Robert Luongo

Of course, this is just my opinion. Just trying to stir up a conversation.

 

[bosoxlover12]

Thomas is one of the GOAT goalies

yet not top 5?

 

[Rice18]

yet not top 5?

Today, no he is not.

 

[sheed]

1. Jimmy Howard
2. Jimmy Howard
3. Jimmy Howard
4. Jimmy Howard
5. Jimmy Howard

:]

 

[Rice18]

1. Jimmy Howard
2. Jimmy Howard
3. Jimmy Howard
4. Jimmy Howard
5. Jimmy Howard

:]

Way to take this serious :diespam:

 

[bosoxlover12]

Today, no he is not.

how is he GOAT, then? this is his best season he's ever had...

 

[sheed]

Way to take this serious :diespam:

Well, I think he was honestly a top 5 goalie this year. If not in the regular season, then obviously the playoffs.

 

[Rice18]

how is he GOAT, then? this is his best season he's ever had...

I stated he is a top 20 goalie IMO.

 

[Rice18]

Well, I think he was honestly a top 5 goalie this year. If not in the regular season, then obviously the playoffs.

I don't disagree.

 

[Yankees2772]

I stated he is a top 20 goalie IMO.

A top 20 goalie of all time, in his best season, in the Stanley Cup... But not a top 5 current goalie?

 

[Rice18]

A top 20 goalie of all time, in his best season, in the Stanley Cup... But not a top 5 current goalie?

Hm, could be argued. This year was not his best year though.

 

[bosoxlover12]

Hm, could be argued. This year was not his best year though.

yeah it is

he has had his highest SV%, lowest GAA, basically best record, most SO, and has brought his team to the Stanley Cup, yet its not his best season?

 

[Yankees2772]

All time highest SV % in a season? Lmao cmon man... I hate when people refuse to admit that they were wrong.

 

[snipezo]

Lulz.

 

[Phil The Thrill]

Vokoun, Backstrom and Brodeur all in the top five? :mellow:

 

[Rice18]

This is a joke. Vokoun, Backstrom and Brodeur all in the top five? :mellow:

lol

 

[Phil The Thrill]

Don't even try arguing with me. Where are guys like Price, Rinne, Thomas, Ward, Lundqvist? These guys all had much better seasons than those three. Hell, James Reimer was better than those three this past season.

 

[Rice18]

Don't even try arguing with me. Where are guys like Price, Rinne, Thomas, Ward, Lundqvist? These guys all had much better seasons than those three. Hell, James Reimer was better than those three this past season.

I just threw in Brodeur, I do think that Vokun and Basktrom deserve it though.

 

[Yankees2772]

What Lundqvist does on the Rangers is ridiculous... He HAS to be in the top 5.

 

[Phil The Thrill]

I just threw in Brodeur, I do think that Vokun and Basktrom deserve it though.

Might want to watch hockey some more. Backstrom or Vokoun did nothing special this past year, and Vokoun is out of his prime.