SI Determines the Best Player in the NFL

[Elite]

Because Revis > Aso

When Peyton Manning, a top 2 QB in the league, can't get the ball to arguably a top 10 WR in the league in a playoff game, you know he's just insane.

 

[bosoxlover12]

Peyton also threw 4 picks versus San Diego....

 

[Elite]

That's cool. Brady also got sacked 5 times by the Jets.

I can throw out irrelevant shit too

 

[bosoxlover12]

How is what i said irrelevant?

you said Peyton, a top NFL QB, couldn't throw versus the Jets in that game

then i said peyton did much worse versus a much worse defense, implying that maybe it was Peyton, not the Jets.

 

[.infamous]

Peyton>Brady and I fuckin hate the colts. And Pats are my second favorite team behind the lions.

 

[kam.]

ASO covered #2 receivers in Oakland alot. Hes not the best CB.

Revis didn't have THAT GREAT of a year as he did last year.

There was an article on twitter I read from a couple of weeks ago that had a few CBs rated higher.

 

[DannyColtsBro]

How is what i said irrelevant?

you said Peyton, a top NFL QB, couldn't throw versus the Jets in that game

then i said peyton did much worse versus a much worse defense, implying that maybe it was Peyton, not the Jets.

LMFAO You for real right now? Out of all games to bash Peyton you pick THAT GAME? I'm confused...

 

[bosoxlover12]

Peyton>Brady and I fuckin hate the colts. And Pats are my second favorite team behind the lions.

this year, brady was better than Peyton by a lot

but in general

Brady=Peyton>>>>Brees, etc

 

[Elite]

How is what i said irrelevant?

you said Peyton, a top NFL QB, couldn't throw versus the Jets in that game

then i said peyton did much worse versus a much worse defense, implying that maybe it was Peyton, not the Jets.

I never said he couldn't throw against the Jets, in case you didn't notice, he had a pretty good game.

What I said was, he couldn't get the ball to Reggie Wayne, one of the better WRs in the league, because he was stranded on Revis Island.

 

[DannyColtsBro]

Nvm im an idiot lol.....

 

[Elite]

ASO covered #2 receivers in Oakland alot. Hes not the best CB.

Revis didn't have THAT GREAT of a year as he did last year.

There was an article on twitter I read from a couple of weeks ago that had a few CBs rated higher.

I wouldn't rate any of the other CBs higher, but he definitely wasn't as dominant this season, he was dealing with that leg injury the whole year.

 

[bosoxlover12]

LMFAO You for real right now? Out of all games to bash Peyton you pick THAT GAME? I'm confused...

im in no means bashing peyton. That was Peyton's worst game of the year, cuz he did so bad against an average/below average defense

 

[DannyColtsBro]

Because Revis > Aso

When Peyton Manning, a top 2 QB in the league, can't get the ball to arguably a top 10 WR in the league in a playoff game, you know he's just insane.

Oh Revis is no doubt insane, Peyton was terrified of him, it completely changed the game having to go to Garcon, White, and Tamme the rest of the game. I just looked at the stats really carefully, and yeah imma go with Revis here.

 

[bestkeptsecret13]

Lach

 

[DannyColtsBro]

im in no means bashing peyton. That was Peyton's worst game of the year, cuz he did so bad against an average/below average defense

San Diego? They were number 1 in the league in YPG, and P usually sucks vs them.

 

[kam.]

I wouldn't rate any of the other CBs higher, but he definitely wasn't as dominant this season, he was dealing with that leg injury the whole year.

Still wasn't as shutdown.

 

[DannyColtsBro]

Asante Samuel was the best corner in the league last year if you look at stats, better than Revis. http://footballoutsiders.com/stat-analysis/2011/best-cornerback-charting-stats-2010

 

[bosoxlover12]

San Diego? They were number 1 in the league in YPG, and P usually sucks vs them.

Really? wow, that surprises me. they dont have that "great" defensive backon that roster..... wow

 

[Yankees2772]

Fuck Asante Samuel and all corners who just play one side of the field.