Who will have the best career?

[dez]

I was going to mention Robiskie but I didn't want to come off as a homer lol. Best hands from this draft, best route running ability, ran the 40 faster then Nicks, and knows more about the game of football then any WR in the draft probably because of his father. Only reason he wasn't picked higher is because Pryor started at QB for the Buckeyes.

Lol his hands arent better then Nicks'

 

[elcheato]

Lol his hands arent better then Nicks'

Just because Nicks' can make the flashy catches and the high light reels does not give him better hands. Robiskie never drops passes, and even makes great ones himself.

 

[A.E]

I'd rather have Robiskie than Hakeem Nicks. I personally think Nicks is a flash-in-the-pan type of player & really won't amount to anything more than what Siniorice Moss has in the NFL.

I see Robiskie is a contributor in the slot, much potential to be a sure-handed #2 in the near future. I like Robiskie to be a Joe Jurevicius type of player.

 

[cruzg24]

Crabtree will be a poor man's Andre Johnson.

 

[dez]

AE you said earlier in this thread you saw Nicks as a 2nd WR, what has changed since?

Ill say this, I watched Nicks' games since he's been at UNC and I watched Robiske (since Ohio St. was on alot) Nicks isnt just a flashy reciever, theres a reason everyone praised him for his hands not highlights. And his hands are better.

 

[elcheato]

Watching Robiskie this year was irrelevant because Pryor is not a passing QB. Two years ago he had his break out season and looked like he would be even more amazing this year until we changed QBs from Boeckman to Pryor. Robiskie definitely has better hands.. The only thing wrong with him is he doesn't have "great speed". He does everything else great.

 

[A.E]

AE you said earlier in this thread you saw Nicks as a 2nd WR, what has changed since?

Ill say this, I watched Nicks' games since he's been at UNC and I watched Robiske (since Ohio St. was on alot) Nicks isnt just a flashy reciever, theres a reason everyone praised him for his hands not highlights. And his hands are better.

I can see Nicks as a #2 but I don't think he's going to do much for the Giants passing game. Put Nicks into the Giants offense & they still have no true #1.

 

[dez]

Watching Robiskie this year was irrelevant because Pryor is not a passing QB. Two years ago he had his break out season and looked like he would be even more amazing this year until we changed QBs from Boeckman to Pryor. Robiskie definitely has better hands.. The only thing wrong with him is he doesn't have "great speed". He does everything else great.

Pryor was much better option then Yates or the other guy they had at QB.

We'll just have to let their play speak for them

 

[elcheato]

Did you watch Pryor pass last year? The guy is a dynamic runner, and has added muscle this year and his throws look good from spring practice, but last year he floated a ton of passes and really could not get the passing game going. In the Fiesta Bowl we had to bring in Boeckman for a deep pass since we were losing, where he threw a bomb to Robiskie who made a diving catch to give the Buckeyes life.

 

[dez]

I have seen Pryor, have you seen Yates or Sexton is the real question.

If so, this debate wouldnt be taking place lol

Nicks put up better numbers last year then Robiskie has ever put up, even with Boekman as his QB

 

[elcheato]

I would say that Pryor with his arm last year probably was one of the worst passers in college.

And with Boeckman, Robiskie had around 1000 yards and 10 TDs, on a team who isn't even known for there passing game. Robiskie was easily a first round talent in scouts eyes before this season with Pryor which for some reason lowered him, no idea why it should.

 

[dez]

I really dont think you saw too much of UNC football, but we'll just have to let their play talk for them...

 

[.s31t]

I like Nicks.
Even like a 2nd Wide out he'll make heads turn.
Strong body... Athletic...
Catches anything thrown to him...
Reminds me of Boldin or Fitzgerald.