Peyton Manning vs Tom Brady

[DC4]

# 3 Time SuberBowl Champion
# 4× Pro Bowl selection (2001, 2004, 2005, 2007)
# 2× All-Pro selection (2005, 2007)
# 3× Super Bowl champion (XXXVI, XXXVIII, XXXIX)
# 2× Super Bowl MVP (XXXVI, XXXVIII)
# Sportsman of the Year (2005)
# SI NFL POY (x1)
# Sporting News Sportsman of the Year (2004, 2007)
# AP Male Athlete of the Year (2007)
# AP NFL MVP (2007)
# AP NFL Offensive Player of the Year (2007)
# New England Patriots All-time leader
(Passing touchdowns)


87–24 (regular season), 101–27 (career) as a starter

3653 ATT 2301 CMP 26,446 YDS 63% CMP 197 TD'S 86 INTS 92/9 RAT






# 9× Pro Bowl selection (1999, 2000, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008)
# 4× First-team All-Pro selection (2003, 2004, 2005, 2008)
# 3× Second-team All-Pro selection(1999, 2000, 2006)
# 3× AP NFL MVP (2003, 2004, 2008)
# Indianapolis Colts All-time leader (Passing Touchdowns and Passing Yards)
# Pro Bowl MVP (2005)
# Super Bowl MVP (XLI)
# NFL MVP (2003 (shared with Steve McNair), 2004, 2008)
# Best NFL Player ESPY Award(2004,[35] 2005[156])
# 9× Pro Bowl Selection (1999–2000, 2002–2008)
# 4× First-team All-Pro (2003, 2004, 2005, 2008)
# 3× Second-team All-Pro (1999, 2000, 2006)
# Bert Bell Award (2003, 2004)
# 1998 NFL All-Rookie First Team
# 2004 AFC Offensive Player of the Year
# 2004 Fedex Express Player of the Year
# 1 Time SuperBowl Champion

5960 ATT 3839 CMP 45,628 YDS 64.4 CMP% 333 TD'S 165 INTS 94.4 RAT

​

 

[Giantmetfan07]

I think Peyton's a better decision maker and quite frankly, I would trust him more with the ball than Tom. Plus tom hash ad recent inuries so we dont know how what will affect his game.

 

[DC4]

couldn't find peytons career record <_<

But I went with peyton aswell

 

[VC15]

I went with Peyton. He may not have as many rings, but he's definately the more skilled QB.

 

[dez]

I picked Brady because he's won more rings and has done it with less to work with up until they got Moss and Welker.

 

[Dice-J]

Tom Brady. He did great and had Peyton's stats with Branch and Givens and won 3 superbowls while Peyton had 2 great WR's and only could win 1. Then Brady goes crazy when he gets the best WR and another pretty good one in Welker.

 

[Oiler35]

Peyton Manning.

Whenever Brady has won anything, he's had a great defense, a great running back, and a great group of wide-outs.


Manning hasn't.

 

[WHO-DEY-BENGALS_18]

This is definitely a toughy. Both QB's are great but I went with Tom Brady.

 

[dez]

Peyton Manning.

Whenever Brady has won anything, he's had a great defense, a great running back, and a great group of wide-outs.


Manning hasn't.

What?

The year the Colts won the SB their defense was at its best, better then any other defense the Colts have had to work woth.

And he has Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Anthony Gonzalez and Dallas Clark and had Brandon Stockley at the wideouts, and no RB? what about Joseph Addai?

That whole statement was wrong.

 

[MapleLeaf]

Brady. Sure Peyton does have a ring and better stats, but If you could draft someone who you know would win you 3 super bowls over 1 super bowl you'd pick the 3. Who cares if he's a system QB, same could be said about every QB who has had success. Brady is probably one if not the best decision maker and most clutch QB's in NFL history

 

[cruzg24]

Ill take the rings over the stats any day of the week. No one remembers Dan Marino as much as they remember John Elway and his 2 super bowls. In football it all comes down to winning. And Brady has won more than Peyton.