Favre VS Rodgers

[A.E]

Of course we will have to do this all season long...so allow me to put the vote to SI right now. Up until this point, who's the better quarterback? When I ask that, I mean in the first 4 weeks of this NFL Season.

Tale of the Tape

Brett Favre
- New York Jets (2-2)
- Wins: Arizona (2-2), Miami (1-2)
- Loses: New England (2-1), San Diego (2-2)
- 87 Completions /124 Attempts
- 935 Passing Yards
- 12 Touchdowns
- 4 Interceptions
- 7.5 Yards Per Completion AVG
- 110.8 QB Rating

Aaron Rodgers
- Green Bay Packers (2-2)
- Wins: Minnesota (1-3), Detroit (0-3)
- Loses: Dallas (3-1), Tampa Bay (3-1)
- 78 Completions /126 Attempts
- 961 Passing Yards
- 6 Touchdowns
- 3 Interceptions
- 7.6 Yards Per Completion AVG
- 91.4 QB Rating

 

[Hoffa]

Favre FTW!

Because Rodgers already has a good team around him, unlike Brett the Jets are a good team but not good as Packers offensively and defensively. So for Brett to come in there and already show what he can still do says a lot for him and what kind of player he is. Brett Favre is once in a life time, Rodgers is just another quarterback!

 

[.GR]

So far this year, I gotta go with Rodgers. The Jets have as many options at receiver as the Pack and a running back nearly as good and Rodgers has made GREAT decisions this year besides one game.

 

[A.E]

Favre FTW!

Because Rodgers already has a good team around him, unlike Brett the Jets are a good team but not good as Packers offensively and defensively. So for Brett to come in there and already show what he can still do says a lot for him and what kind of player he is. Brett Favre is once in a life time, Rodgers is just another quarterback!

Meh...beating up on Miami & Arizona's secondary doesn't impress me that much.

Favre's heaving up some serious jump balls...and that sh*t didn't work against SD & NE, more respectable defenses.

 

[Hoffa]

Meh...beating up on Miami & Arizona's secondary doesn't impress me that much.

Favre's heaving up some serious jump balls...and that sh*t didn't work against SD & NE, more respectable defenses.

Just to tell you know he didn't throw the ball enough in the San Diego game and that is why they lost.

 

[RipCity32]

To be honest, if you take either at this point due to how good they have played, your team is likely to still be the same with either QB at the helm. But I'd take Farve, just because his name is Farve.

 

[A.E]

Just to tell you know he didn't throw the ball enough in the San Diego game and that is why they lost.

You can't throw the ball when nobody is open & you don't have the time to throw.

 

[Hoffa]

You can't throw the ball when nobody is open & you don't have the time to throw.

When you are at the goal line and you attempt to rush the ball 3 times yeah that says you are an idiot of a coach since Brett Farve is your quarterback you can at least throw the ball once and see what you get to win the bloody game eh?

 

[.GR]

When you are at the goal line and you attempt to rush the ball 3 times yeah that says you are an idiot of a coach since Brett Farve is your quarterback you can at least throw the ball once and see what you get to win the bloody game eh?

Didnt he throw a pick that game in the red zone?