Nash Won't Rule Out Playing For A Texas Team In Future

[Pugz]

And I don't think Nash has ever had knee surgery....or the need to have surgery. I think that Nash is a better shooter, and passer (barely) but Kidd obviously has the top in rebounding. Another thing is that Kidd doesn't seem to make the players around him a lot better like Nash has done with the Suns. Cause before Nash got there, Joe Joe wasn't playing very well or Diaw or Barbosa...etc.

Well some of that is right..
But I would still take Kidd over Nash.

 

[dez]

And I don't think Nash has ever had knee surgery....or the need to have surgery. I think that Nash is a better shooter, and passer (barely) but Kidd obviously has the top in rebounding. Another thing is that Kidd doesn't seem to make the players around him a lot better like Nash has done with the Suns. Cause before Nash got there, Joe Joe wasn't playing very well or Diaw or Barbosa...etc.

DJT, I have NO IDEA what you are talking about.

First off, Kidd is a WAY better passer then Nash, Nash is just "flashier" and Kidd doesnt make the players around him better? PLEASE look at what he's got to work with compared to Nash:

C N.Kristic
PF J.Collins
SF R.Jefferson
SG V.Carter
SG A.Wright


A.Stoudemire
PF B.Diaw
SF S.Marion
SF G.Hill
SG L.Barbosa
SG R.Bell

now put J.Kidd on that team and they would be just as good if not better. He has less to work with and they are still constantly in the playoffs. I'd take Kidd over Nash ANYDAY b/c he is a pure PG Pass first, Play D second, Rebound third and SHOOT LAST

 

[DJT]

DJT, I have NO IDEA what you are talking about.

First off, Kidd is a WAY better passer then Nash, Nash is just "flashier" and Kidd doesnt make the players around him better? PLEASE look at what he's got to work with compared to Nash:

C N.Kristic
PF J.Collins
SF R.Jefferson
SG V.Carter
SG A.Wright

A.Stoudemire
PF B.Diaw
SF S.Marion
SF G.Hill
SG L.Barbosa
SG R.Bell

now put J.Kidd on that team and they would be just as good if not better. He has less to work with and they are still constantly in the playoffs. I'd take Kidd over Nash ANYDAY b/c he is a pure PG Pass first, Play D second, Rebound third and SHOOT LAST

Ah but when did all of the Suns players actually start getting recognition??? After Nash came. And if you haven't checked Kidd has been playing like crap lately while Nash got 17 assists in his game before last and 18 in his last game, all with only 10 points. Sure Nash doesn't camp down by the hoop looking for rebounds, he has Marion and Amare to do that, and your saying Nash is quicker to shoot, which is true, because he can make the shots he takes, whereas Kidd is not as consistent. But Nash doesn't shoot unless he is feeling it, or his team needs him to.

 

[Pugz]

Ah but when did all of the Suns players actually start getting recognition??? After Nash came. And if you haven't checked Kidd has been playing like crap lately while Nash got 17 assists in his game before last and 18 in his last game, all with only 10 points. Sure Nash doesn't camp down by the hoop looking for rebounds, he has Marion and Amare to do that, and your saying Nash is quicker to shoot, which is true, because he can make the shots he takes, whereas Kidd is not as consistent. But Nash doesn't shoot unless he is feeling it, or his team needs him to.

Lets just stop this whole thing right now.

Kidd and Nash are the TOP PG's in the league.
They are BOTH HoFer's.

But I would rather have Kidd.

 

[DJT]

Lets just stop this whole thing right now.

Kidd and Nash are the TOP PG's in the league.
They are BOTH HoFer's.

But I would rather have Kidd.

Its ok to keep this going, its not like we are bashing each other or anything, we are just debating about who is better.

 

[Pugz]

Its ok to keep this going, its not like we are bashing each other or anything, we are just debating about who is better.

I know but these two are not debateable Kidd is the better passer Nash is the better shooter but they are both the best right now.

 

[DJT]

I know but these two are not debateable Kidd is the better passer Nash is the better shooter but they are both the best right now.

But I disagree with that, Nash had 18 assists in his last game, and 17 before that, Kidd usually never puts up those kind of numbers in the assists column. He just gets enough to get himself a triple double.

 

[Pugz]

But I disagree with that, Nash had 18 assists in his last game, and 17 before that, Kidd usually never puts up those kind of numbers in the assists column. He just gets enough to get himself a triple double.

Nash's teammates are better they can score more easily.
Kidd's teammates may not shot it right away or they'll just pass it up.

 

[.loggie]

I like Nash better cause hes more of a team player but Kidd could average a triple double. But then again he got most of his rebounds because they were a small team.

 

[DJT]

Nash's teammates are better they can score more easily.
Kidd's teammates may not shot it right away or they'll just pass it up.

Yea true, thats why I want Kidd to go somewhere with a good supporting cast, cause then I think people would see that Nash is better, because Kidd can't hit the shot when his team needs him to like Nash, and they both can make great passes, and make their teammates better.

But Kidd does have a decent supporting cast, just look VC and RJ.

 

[Josh10_10]

I know but these two are not debateable Kidd is the better passer Nash is the better shooter but they are both the best right now.

Nash is the better passer. Also, Kidd's supporting cast really isn't that shabby... Carter, RJ, and Nenad..

 

[DJT]

Nash is the better passer. Also, Kidd's supporting cast really isn't that shabby... Carter, RJ, and Nenad..

Thank you, thats what i've been trying to say this whole time.

 

[Pugz]

Thank you, thats what i've been trying to say this whole time.

His team is just Carter and RJ Nenad isn't doing that well right now.
Nash has a whole team of players that will knock down a shot and plus Nash gets all of his dimes cuz he throws oops like a mad man and his little pick and roll with Amare.

 

[dez]

I like Nash better cause hes more of a team player

More of a TEAM player?...... :blink: ........that makes no sense to me at all.

 

[dez]

Nash is the better passer. Also, Kidd's supporting cast really isn't that shabby... Carter, RJ, and Nenad..

no their not bad but they arent as good as Nash's supporting cast, all Im saying is Kidd is the better POINT GUARD, he makes the players around him better, as does Nash. But the difference b/t the two is simple.

Kidd is a triple double machine, Nash is a double double machine.....which would you rather have?

 

[DJT]

no their not bad but they arent as good as Nash's supporting cast, all Im saying is Kidd is the better POINT GUARD, he makes the players around him better, as does Nash. But the difference b/t the two is simple.

Kidd is a triple double machine, Nash is a double double machine.....which would you rather have?

Easily Nash, he doesn't need to rebound and he is also a heck of alot more capable of getting 20 and 20 then 10 and 10 and 10.

And 20 and 20 > 3 10s.

 

[dez]

Easily Nash, he doesn't need to rebound and he is also a heck of alot more capable of getting 20 and 20 then 10 and 10 and 10.

you fail to realize this Kidd HAS to rebound who else does it on their team?

and a PG isnt supposed to score 20PPG its a plus, yes, but I think 10 10 and 10 is ALOT more effective.

 

[Pugz]

you fail to realize this Kidd HAS to rebound who else does it on their team?

and a PG isnt supposed to score 20PPG its a plus, yes, but I think 10 10 and 10 is ALOT more effective.

Your Right Kidd doesn't need to score 20ppg I mean niehter does Nash but Nash does...

Kidd is PASS FIRST...
Nash passes firts too but he will also take his shot before Kidd would.

 

[DJT]

you fail to realize this Kidd HAS to rebound who else does it on their team?

and a PG isnt supposed to score 20PPG its a plus, yes, but I think 10 10 and 10 is ALOT more effective.

Kidd doesn't have to rebound, he could leave it to Kristic, Williams, Allen, Collins...etc. But he probably likes getting triple doubles, I don't blame him I would to, so he runs in their and gets rebounds.

Your Right Kidd doesn't need to score 20ppg I mean niehter does Nash but Nash does...

Kidd is PASS FIRST...
Nash passes firts too but he will also take his shot before Kidd would.

Thats because Nash knows he will make it, and he also knows when his team needs him to take it and make it.

 

[dez]

Kidd doesn't have to rebound, he could leave it to Kristic, Williams, Allen, Collins...etc. But he probably likes getting triple doubles, I don't blame him I would to, so he runs in their and gets rebounds.

......... If Kristic, Collins, and Allen could rebound dont you think they would?